My first thought upon reading a new shareholder derivative complaint accusing directors and officers of JPMorgan Chase,
Wells Fargo and Bank of America of facilitating a pyramid scheme
by extending a total of $1.2 billion in credit to the
controversial nutrition company Herbalife was that it was an
interesting new development in the weird hedge-fund showdown
between Herbalife short-seller William Ackman of Pershing Square
and Herbalife investor Carl Icahn. My second thought, when I
noticed that the pro se plaintiff was a lawyer named Daniel
Ravicher, was, "Wait. That can't be Dan Ravicher of the Public
Patent Foundation."
But it is. The well-known IP public interest lawyer, who's
co-counsel with the American Civil Liberties Union in the Myriad gene patent case now before the U.S. Supreme Court, is
moonlighting as a private lawyer in the Herbalife derivative
suit and in a companion fraud complaint against Icahn, also
filed Wednesday in federal court in Manhattan. In a phone
interview Ravicher told me that he's stepping out of the realm
of intellectual property because he's convinced Herbalife is
taking advantage of unwary, unsophisticated consumers. His
girlfriend, he said, knows someone who became an Herbalife
distributor and nearly became one herself. "This struck a chord
with me personally," he said. "Herbalife is hurting people."
Besides, Ravicher said, there's not that much difference
between suing to bring attention to an alleged fraud and suing
over wrongfully asserted patents (as PubPatent did in its false
marking campaign a few years back) or activism to do away with
software patents, another of Ravicher's causes.
In Herbalife, he's put his money where his mouth is. As my
Reuters colleague Jon Stempel has reported, Ravicher took a big short on Herbalife stock in December, at around the time that
Pershing hedge fund manager Ackman went public with his account
that the company is "a well-managed pyramid scheme." When Icahn,
who is known to be feuding with Ackman, disclosed his supportfor (and huge investment in) Herbalife last month, Ravicher lost
$75,000. I asked Ravicher whether his short position in the
stock could be seen as a motive for filing suits that might
drive down Herbalife's share price. "They can make that
argument," he said. On the other hand, Ravicher said, if he
hadn't lost money on his Herbalife short, he wouldn't have
standing to sue Icahn.
Ravicher also told me that he bought stock in BofA, JPMorgan
and Wells Fargo specifically to establish standing in his suit
against the banks, which is the first shareholder derivative
case he has filed. He's already addressed (albeit cursorily) one
potential pitfall of derivative litigation: demand futility.
Earlier this month, Ravicher sent letters to the CEO and general
counsel of each of the banks, identifying himself as a
shareholder, laying out his claim that Herbalife is a pyramid
scheme and asking each bank to withdraw the credit it had
extended to the company. Only Wells Fargo responded, according
to Ravicher's complaint, and it said the bank would not take
action against a customer based on a third party's allegations.
The banks' failure to act on the evidence he sent about the
purported Herbalife fraud, Ravicher contends, means that it
would be futile to make additional demands that they drop the
credit line. That futility, he said in the derivative complaint,
entitles him to sue on behalf of the banks.
If BofA, JPMorgan and Wells Fargo agree to shut down
Herbalife's credit facilities, Ravicher said, he'll drop the
derivative suit. "I really expect the banks to do the right
thing here," he told me. "This is not a business they want to be
in."
Otherwise, if Icahn and the banks continue to back
Herbalife, he said, he's ready for them to make an issue of his
financial motives: "If they do attack me personally - and I
expect they will - that just means they don't have a response to
my argument."
Representatives of Herbalife and the three banks named in
the derivative suit declined my requests for comment. An Icahn
representative didn't respond to requests by Reuters for
comment.
Follow us on Twitter: @AlisonFrankel, @ReutersLegal | Like us on Facebook