Feb 6 (Reuters) - The worst of the summer-hiring slump
for law students may be over, according to law school
administrators and management consultants.
A pickup in litigation and transactional work over the last
year, along with projections of modestly better revenue and
earnings for 2012, is prompting some law firms to reinvigorate
their summer hiring plans, said Paula Alvary, principal of
consulting firm Hoffman Alvary, which advises law firms on
strategy and management.
The good news started to gather in 2011. A new assessment
found that several top schools saw an increase in law firms'
summer hiring of their students last year, confirming previous
reports that summer-associate hiring has begun to recover.
"Firms are making a very, very cautious return to summer
hiring," said Alvary. "They are treading carefully, but they
don't want to be caught short two to three years from now."
While students should not count on a return to the
eye-popping numbers of the boom era -- when larger firms hired
dozens of associates every summer -- the market has been showing
positive signs, said Douglas Rush, a professor of education at
Saint Louis University in St. Louis, Missouri.
"Firms are again starting to hire for summer positions,
though not in the numbers they did before the recession," he
said.
Last August, The American Lawyer released the results of its
2011 survey of law-firm hiring, which found that the average
summer class size at more than 100 law firms was up 25 percent
from 2010.
MID-LEVEL FIRMS REASSESSING
To get a better sense of the hiring impact on individual law
schools, Reuters asked a group of top-rated law schools for
their most up-to-date year-to-year data.
At New York University School of Law -- currently ranked No.
6 by US News & World Report -- preliminary data show that about
70 percent of incoming third-year students got summer associate
positions in 2011, up 15 percentage points from 2010. At No.
5-ranked University of Chicago, the number was 77 percent, up
eight points from 2010. The increase was three percentage points
at No. 1-ranked Yale, and four percentage points at No. 7-ranked
University of Michigan.
Students at top-tier schools may be experiencing more of a
improvement in summer hiring than those at lower-tier schools,
which tend to send fewer students to the top firms, Alvary said.
"Top-end firms continue to rely heavily on summer associate
programs, but mid-level firms are reassessing their processes
for training lawyers," she said. "There's a differentiation in
the market."
Summer associate jobs -- long sought-after for serving as
feeders to well-paid jobs after graduation -- became tougher to
get in the wake of the recession, even for students at the most
elite law schools, as firms slashed their summer programs.
The dropoff was steepest between the summers of 2009 and
2010, according to data compiled by Harvard. In 2009 the top 100
law firms offered approximately 6,123 summer-associate
positions. One year later, that number fell to 3,211 -- a
reduction of nearly 50 percent.
"The impact of 2008's financial crisis wasn't really felt at
law schools until the following year," said Irene Dorzback,
assistant dean of career services at NYU. "Students interviewing
in 2009 for summer associate jobs in 2010 ... were hit the
hardest."
JOBS 'DIDN'T FALL INTO ANYONE'S LAP'
The sudden decline is reflected in the experiences of
top-ten-ranked law schools. At NYU, 55 percent of incoming
third-year students held summer positions in 2010, down from 80
percent a year earlier. At Michigan, the drop was to 51 percent
from 75 percent; at the University of Chicago the numbers were
69 percent and 89 percent, respectively.
Among the elite of the elite, however, the dropoff was not
as steep. At Harvard Law School -- ranked No. 2 -- approximately
77 percent of incoming third-year students had summer associate
jobs in 2010, a drop from 85 percent in 2009, according to Mark
Weber, Harvard Law's assistant dean for career services.
"We have very good employment numbers, but the jobs didn't
fall into anyone's lap," said Weber. "Students had to work
harder and expand the scope of their searches. So, many landed
(summer associate) work at firms, but was it at the firm they
wanted, in the location they wanted, doing type work they wanted
to do?"
At Yale, there was no perceptible dropoff between 2009 and
2010: 72 percent of rising third-year Yale students took summer
associate jobs each year.
(Reporting by Moira Herbst)
Follow us on Twitter: @ReutersLegal