Thomson Reuters News & Insight
Featured Content from WESTLAW

New York Legal

  •  
  •  

Court room, 60 Centre Street, New York. REUTERS Chip East

Thirty NY Supreme Court seats to be filled on Tuesday

11/5/2012 COMMENTS (0)

By Jessica Dye and Daniel Wiessner 

NEW YORK, Nov 5 (Reuters) - As New Yorkers struggle to recover from Sandy, residents on Tuesday will hit the polls to cast their votes in 30 state Supreme Court races and in a number of local judicial elections. At least 143,000 voters in New York City have been assigned to new polling places as a result of flooding or power outages caused by the monster storm.

Here are some of the races to watch in the state's four Appellate Division departments, each of which is comprised of several judicial districts.

FIRST DEPARTMENT (which includes Manhattan and the Bronx) 

* In the Bronx, two candidates are vying to replace Surrogate Court Judge Lee Holzman. Holzman, who has reached the mandatory retirement age of 70, is facing misconduct charges brought by the state judicial conduct commission for allegedly failing to fire a lawyer in his court who billed thousands of dollars in advance fees before performing any work. He has denied any wrongdoing. The candidates seeking Holzman's seat are Democrat Nelida Malave-Gonzalez, a Bronx Civil Court judge and acting Supreme Court justice, and Republican Frances O'Leary, a retired attorney.

* There are no contested elections in Manhattan, where four candidates are on the ballot to fill four seats on the Supreme Court. Justices are elected to 14-year terms.

SECOND DEPARTMENT (which includes Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Long Island, and five other counties

* Twelve candidates -- an equal number of Republicans and Democrats -- are vying for six Supreme Court seats in Long Island's 10th Judicial District, which covers Nassau and Suffolk counties. Of those competing, two candidates sit on the Appellate Division, Second Department: Justices Peter Skelos and Leonard Austin. While Appellate Division justices are appointed from a statewide pool of elected Supreme Court justices, they must seek re-election when their Supreme Court terms expire. Justice James Catterson, who was elected to the Supreme Court in Suffolk County and sits in the First Department, is also a 10th District candidate.

* In the 9th Judicial District, which includes Westchester County and other northern suburbs of New York City, Supreme Court Justice John LaCava and Acting Supreme Court Justice Gerald Loehr are among seven candidates vying for three Supreme Court seats.

* In Brooklyn, five candidates -- including Second Department Justice Cheryl Chambers; Barry Kamins, administrative judge of the New York City Criminal Court; and William Miller, a criminal court judge and acting Supreme Court justice -- are running for three openings on the Kings County Supreme Court.

THIRD DEPARTMENT (which includes Saratoga and Binghamton)

* In the Third Judicial District, which includes Albany County, five candidates are running for two Supreme Court seats. Among them are Appellate Division Justices Bernard Malone and Michael Kavanagh. Democrats Stephan Schick and Richard Mott and Working Families Party candidate Lawrence Weissman, all of them practicing attorneys, also have tossed their hats in the ring. A loss for Malone or Kavanagh, who are both Republicans, would open a vacancy in the Third Department, which would be filled by Governor Andrew Cuomo, a Democrat.

* There are eight candidates seeking four seats in the 4th Judicial District, which covers Saratoga and 10 other counties. Montgomery Supreme Court Justice Joseph Sise and acting Supreme Court Justices Felix Catena and Christine Clark are among the candidates.

FOURTH DEPARTMENT (which includes Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse)

* In the 7th Judicial District, which includes Monroe County, where Rochester is located, Supreme Court Justice David Michael Barry and Acting Supreme Court Justice Gail Donofrio, both Republicans, are facing challenges from Democrats Sean Gleanson, an attorney, and Acting Rochester City Court Judge Scott Odorisi.

 Follow us on Twitter @ReutersLegal | Like us on Facebook    


Register or log in to comment.

© 2013 Thomson Reuters