By Chris Francescani
NEW YORK, Dec 6 (Reuters) - New York's largest civil
liberties group filed a federal lawsuit Thursday against state
corrections officials on behalf of a convicted rapist who spent
26 months in solitary confinement after a non-violent offense in
his cell.
The lawsuit is the latest challenge to standards by which
some 80,000 inmates a day are confined up to 23 hours a day in
isolation or with another inmate inside cells as small as a
parking spot.
Critics claim solitary confinement is a form of torture that
inflicts lasting psychological damage and is meted out in many
states too arbitrarily and, increasingly, too often.
New York prison officials declined to comment on the lawsuit
but have said in the past it is sometimes necessary to remove
inmates from the rest of the prison population.
The lawsuit, filed by the New York Civil Liberties Union in
federal court in Manhattan, asserts Leroy Peoples was placed in
solitary confinement for nearly 26 months after jail guards
discovered forged legal documents in his cell.
Peoples, 30, was sentenced to 16 years in prison after
pleading guilty in 2005 to raping two women at gunpoint in
Queens, New York, according to prosecutors.
"New York's prison authorities permit the use extreme
isolation ... as a disciplinary tool of first resort for
violating almost any prison rule, no matter how minor," NYCLU
Executive Director Donna Lieberman said in a statement.
Between 2007 and 2011, New York State prison officials
segregated inmates 302 times for "smoking in an undesignated
area," 135 times for "wasting food," 114 times for "littering"
and 234 times for "untidy cell or person," according to a recent
NYCLU study of state prison segregation records.
A spokesman for the New York State Department of Corrections
said the agency doesn't comment on ongoing litigation. In
October, state corrections commissioner Brian Fischer responded
to the NYCLU study.
"As a society removes those individuals who commit crimes,
so too must we remove from general population inmates who
violate the Department's code of conduct and who threaten the
safety and security of our facilities," Fischer said in a
statement, which did not address non-violent offenses.
"The possession of drugs, cell phones and weapons pose a
serious threat within this ... system."
There were 563 assaults on staff and 666 inmate assaults on
other inmates last year, out of a population of about 56,000,
state corrections records show.
In June, a federal lawsuit was filed on behalf of mentally
ill prisoners isolated at Colorado's so-called Supermax prison,
and the U.S. Senate held a hearing for the first time to examine
the use of isolation in federal prisons.
About half of prison suicides occur in solitary confinement,
according to Senate testimony in June from Craig Haney, a
psychology professor who has studied prison isolation for 30
years, despite most states segregating less than 10 percent of
its prison population.
About 8 percent of New York's inmates are held in isolation,
a slightly higher rate than in federal prisons, according to
federal statistics.
A 2007 New York state prisons report -- the most recent
available -- found 83 percent of New York's prison population
showed a need for substance abuse treatment.
Follow us on Twitter @ReutersLegal | Like us on Facebook